Kashmiri Shaivism

First of all, it should be clarified here that the following text can only serve as an orientation to Śaiva Tantra and Kashmiri Shaivism. Those who "really want to know" are encouraged to read the writings of the appropriate authorities, such as Alexis Sanderson, Mark Dyczkowski, Christopher Wallis, among others.

Kashmiri Shaivism was an astonishing development in ancient India. It can be seen as an expression of a deeply rooted urge for self-knowledge in consciousness and reached its heyday around 800-1200 AD in the society of the Kashmir Valley, as well as to the northwest, in Uddiyāna, the Swat Valley in present-day Pakistan. It was often extensively supported by the ruling royal houses, and the rulers themselves were sometimes Tantrics. Temples, schools and universities for research and teaching about consciousness arose, as well as countless writings on the subject. All this was largely destroyed with the Muslim invasion, who considered any non-Islamic thinking harmful, at the beginning of the 13th century and in the following centuries, especially with the incursion of the radical orthodox Pashtuns.

Only a small part of the tantric writings was preserved by the so-called Pandit families, who were entrusted with this task, and saved through handwritten copies over generations. Some errors arose because most members of these families were no longer proficient in Sanskrit. Only with the Sikhs at the beginning of the 19th century and later the English was there a renewed promotion of spirituality in Kashmir, and Sanskrit scholars began to correct a large part (though not all) of the errors in the writings of Kashmiri Shaivism. With the handover of the English colony to the Hindu government in 1949, this support also dried up, and in the hope of continuing this process of revival of the writings, they were passed on to university libraries around the world, where they initially gathered dust and were gradually rediscovered and researched from the 1960s onwards.

Meanwhile, there were also some lines in Kashmir, which was Muslim-ruled until about 1700 AD, as well as in other regions of India, in which the teachings of Kashmiri Shaivism were confidentially passed from masters to students. The last known guru of the Trika line (the main tradition of non-dual Kashmiri Tantra) was Swami Lakśmanjoo, who died in 1991.

Kashmiri Shaivism arose when spirituality in contemporary India was largely understood as a ritual formalism recited from the Vedas, which - similar to the priests of the medieval Catholic Church and today's evangelical rock stars - was institutionalised by Brahmin priests and probably used for the purposes of power and ego maintenance. In connection with the worldly teachings of the Bhagavad-gītā and the Patañjali Yoga influenced by the teachings and practices of the Buddha, Kashmiri Tantrism (Tantra = "teaching") ultimately emerged.

There is evidence that Kashmiri Shaivism was a significant current in Indian spirituality for several centuries and permeated and influenced other directions, such as Buddhism, ultimately up to Hatha Yoga, which emerged from the rudiments of Tantrism (and contrary to popular belief does not derive directly from Patañjali's teachings). Along the Silk Road, Kashmiri Shaivism radiated as far as Tibet, where it significantly inspired Tibetan Buddhism.

While spiritual systems of thought fundamentally have the unity or oneness with the Divine, i.e. the abolition of duality, as their subject, they often seem to remain stuck in this idea, i.e. either in philosophy and the study of sacred texts or in a ritual yogic practice that sometimes seems self-sufficient and only theoretically offers the possibility of reaching a goal through effort and discipline and perhaps only in a later life, thus eventually overcoming duality. This is inherent, for example, in Vaiśnava Tantra with its practice of Bhakti Yoga. This also applies to the Shaivite lines of the so-called "right hand," i.e. dualistic Shaivism, such as Śaivasiddhānta (a comprehensive overview of all Shaivite currents can be found in Mark Dyczkowski's "The Vibration of Consciousness"). When Kashmiri Shaivism is mentioned below, the non-dual currents are meant (i.e. the "left-hand path"), of which Trika, Krama and Kaula are the most significant lines.

 

A Counter-Model

Kashmiri Shaivism represents the non-dual counter-model to Brahmanism and the institutionalised understanding of spirituality in Indian society. Its clear aim is to bring about the realisation of consciousness already in this life, starting from the premise that as sentient beings we are nothing other than contracted points of self-awareness of what we call God. It is therefore no longer about producing a special quality of consciousness and acquiring spiritual achievements, but simply about recognising that we already are what we want to be or can be nothing else and fully embodying this (of course from the perspective of what we are, not from the perspective of what we believe ourselves to be). From this perspective, there is no need to worry about what we believe ourselves to be (Vikalpas) or about any biographical issues and deep conditioning (Saṃskāras) or fantasies about lack and inadequacy. Some psychotherapists might perk up at this point.

From this tantric perspective, we recognise that we are not only islands that may see each other but ultimately must remain separate, but one single landmass. That we are not only the fish but the whole ocean. Not only the whole iceberg but also all the melted water. 

From a philosophy of religion perspective, Kashmiri Shaivism corresponds to monistic theism. God is the One that is all and contains all that could be subject or object.

The ego with its limited consciousness is from the non-dual tantric perspective merely a contracted form of God, and therefore - due to its limited perception (which is necessary to be an individual, for without limitation of perception it would encompass everything and could no longer be a separate individual) - naturally always mistaken about the meanings of things. Everything we believe exists only as a story ("layers" of thoughts or movements in consciousness that were once temporarily stored ("stored" -> "stories"), one single "story," one might say). Even the belief that one is in the awareness of reality. They are only stories about reality. It is therefore not necessary to worry about what we think and believe. Nor is it necessary to worry about the objects of our experience, which we charge with emotional energy and thereby give them "weight" and meaning.

In this respect, Kashmiri Shaivism thus begins with the solution. Strictly speaking, from this perspective there has never been a problem, for everything is already perfect because everything is an expression of the one indivisible Divine. The Divine sometimes appears very mundane. An elaborate system of tantric practices (Upāyas) serves this process of insight.

The tradition of Trika, the Trinity, deals essentially with the integration of the position of the knower (perceiver), the process of knowing (perception) and the known (perceived, or also: subject - verb - object - quite similar, by the way, to the Christian "Father - Holy Spirit - Son") and the inseparability of this trinity ("3+1"). 

Terms like "Kashmiri Tantra" or "Kashmiri Shaivism" are quite popular in today's neo-tantra scene, partly due to the work of the writer and tantric teacher Daniel Odier, who here with an implicit claim to interpretative authority has created a romanticised narrative with this term relying on a source accessible only to himself. Much of it, such as his interpretation of the Tandava dance or Kashmiri massage, is not found in the written traditions, although it can partly be derived from them with goodwill. Odier is quite controversial and ultimately belongs to the neo-tantrics (see also https://dancingdragon.co.za/tandava-takedown).

 

Kashmiri Shaivism and the Vijñāna Bhairava Tantra

The oldest known, fully preserved written record of the teachings of this time is the Vijñāna Bhairava Tantra, which originated around the 8th century AD. 

The Vijñāna Bhairava Tantra (VBT) reflects in 163 verses a dialogue between Bhairavi (Parvati, the "consort" of Śiva) and Bhairava (one of the names of Śiva), whereby Bhairavi, who as a goddess already knows all the answers, demonstrates to us how to ask skillfully in order to penetrate the essence of things. Bhairava's answers consist of the exposition of 112 teachings (upadeśa), from which mostly meditative practices (Yuktis) arise, each teaching revealing the Divine and each Yukti making it experientially accessible to us. Thus, Yukti 1, a simple Kundalini practice, already leads to deep experiences. Besides Kundalini Yoga, these Yuktis include the Uccāra practice, Dhyana and energy body work, Lāya Yoga, Vipaśyanā, Śāmbhava practice, among others (see also Tantra Yoga).

The Vijñāna Bhairava Tantra has been commented on far more often than translated, and so it happens that many commentators only commented on the translations of a few translators, some of whom were not always quite sure about their interpretation of Sanskrit themselves, such as Śivopathyāya, whose translation from the 17th century, about 900 years after the first writing down of the Vijñāna Bhairava Tantra, was followed by many with missionary zeal. And so it happens that one finds very different versions and interpretations, for example, in Osho's "Book of Secrets," in Daniel Odier's  "Tantra Yoga. The Path to the Highest Knowledge" or with Swami Lakśmanjoo. Prominent examples are the above-mentioned creative representations of the VBT by Daniel Odier or Osho, both largely based on the version by Paul Reps. Paul Reps was a student of Swami Laksmanjoo and interpreted in a very poetic way the comments of Swami Laksmanjoo on Bettina Bäumer's VBT translation (see also C. Wallis VBT blog). Swami Laksmanjoo himself never translated anything from Sanskrit. All this may invite one to form one's own opinion. Here a small excursus.

Other early sources on the subject of Kashmiri Shaivism are dated between the 3rd century BC and the 5th century AD.

The so-called "great Kashmiri line" then began in the 8th century with Vasu Gupta, the author of the Śiva Sutras, who was the first to comment on the Vijñāna Bhairava Tantra and other early texts, followed by his student Kallata, the author of the Spandakarika. A line of transmissions followed to Utpala Deva, Lakṣmana Gupta, Abhinava Gupta and Kṣemarāja.

Abhinava Gupta (approx. 10th-11th century) integrated the 64 Tantras (or "Agamas" = revelation texts) available to him at the time into the encyclopedia called Tantrāloka (roughly translated as "Enlightenment about" or "Illumination of" Tantra), alongside his supplementary work Tantrāsara, the current foundational work on the subject of Kashmiri Shaivism or Trika.

Important written sources of Kashmiri Shaivism include:

The Śiva Sutras (Vasu Gupta)

The Spandakarika (Kallata)

The Pratyabhijnahrdayam (Kṣemaraja) 

Added were the writings of the Krama tradition, which originated in the valley of Uddiyāna northwest of Kashmir, such as

The Chummās

The Vathulanātha Sutras

Also added was the Kaulajñānanirnāyatantra, which was said to have been written in the 7th-8th century (according to some) by Matsyendranath in Assam. 

Abhinava Gupta integrated the sequence of the different schools:

Krama, Kaula, Spanda and Pratyabhijña.

Tantrism brought a lot of movement into the entrenched contemporary social narratives of the society adhering to Vedanta and Samkhya philosophy. For example, the Kaula tradition recommended breaking Brahmin prohibitions to free oneself from socio-cultural conditioning (alcohol, meat, grains, fish, sexual union). This may sometimes have been a reason why Kashmiri Shaivism exerted a certain attraction on the Brahmins and Buddhist monks of its time, whose vows and traditions largely forbade the enjoyment of worldly pleasures. It may also have contributed to the development of Tibetan Buddhism, whose teaching of Mahāmudrā ("great gesture") shows strong analogies to Kashmiri Shaivism. However, it is also sensible to consider that the consumption of alcohol, meat etc. was by no means seen as attractive or pleasurable in Indian society at that time. It was rather regarded as disgusting and repulsive, and the ancient Tantrics, aware of their own deep socio-cultural conditioning, practised overcoming this restrictive social narrative (interestingly, Swami Lakśmanjoo, the best-known Kashmiri master of the 20th century, expressed himself in a decidedly moralistic way regarding meat consumption and emphasised in this context the increase of karma, although karma is not really significant in non-duality). The classic tantric union ritual (Maithunā) was also little inspired by pleasure. It was about connecting with a partner in love, whom one initially found sexually rather repulsive. This is probably more for advanced practitioners!

To better understand the attraction of Kashmiri Shaivism to religions, it is necessary to realise that there is a fundamental difference in the understanding of reality between Hindu-Vedantic and most Buddhist systems of thought and Tantrism:

For Hinduism, Vedanta and most Buddhist paths, reality is illusory, and so is the one who perceives it. It therefore quickly seems sensible to detach oneself from desire and emotions and let everything rest "unfired" in the infinity of non-self (Nirvana = "no fire"), which is regarded as "liberation," "awakening," etc. In contrast, the Tantrics consider the world to be real, so it is important to appreciate and integrate the entirety of sensory and emotional experiences. The Shaivites regard desire as absolute movement, as the creative aspect of Śiva and not as an expression of lack. At the same time, it makes no sense to seek fulfilment by grasping for an element one "is" oneself and thus fragmenting the self (which of course is not possible. Rather, this illusory world of duality is created in this way). Remaining in desire, instead of grasping for objects of desire, therefore characterises non-dual Tantrism among other things. 

With regard to Buddhism, whose system of thought is based on the characteristics of existence Annica (impermanence, transience), Dhukka (the unsatisfactory, painful nature of objects of desire) and Anatta (the lack of essence or emptiness of things, which - including the self - have no "core" and depend only on dependent origination), it can be noted that here the assumption exists that desire is not possible without grasping for an object and thus triggering a cascade of suffering. This, in turn, some Buddhists have recognised as attachment to a belief. 

While some deconstruct the reality believed to be an illusion into "non-self," for the Shaivites and Tantrics only the "self" remains, which encompasses everything as Śiva in all its manifestations of reality (the 36 Tattvas).