Tantra: Sex, the Arts and Life
(From C. Titmuss: “The Buddha of Love. Essays on the Power of the Heart.”)
The wise see an action as it really arises. They are skilled in the fruits of actions. Sn. 653
The Buddhist wisdom teacher and journalist Christopher Titmuss here presents a 
nuanced portrayal of Tantra from a Buddhist perspective. It becomes clear on the one hand how deeply he has engaged with the subject and at the same time partially followed the narratives of Neotantra. This is indicated, among other things, by his exposition of the Kaubjika chakra system or his understanding of mudras, which traditionally do not only concern the hands. The inconsistencies felt here may have prompted him to appeal to "squeeze the honey out of the old teachings" for today’s times. Here is his - in my view very worthwhile - essay:
"As human beings, we are questioning creatures, and at the same time we run the risk of succumbing to naive beliefs or cultural indoctrination and are unable to look beyond our immediate horizon. Sometimes our research and exploration extend far into the distant past. We can draw conclusions from texts written many centuries ago. We find ancient views in psychology, philosophy, religion and science. The wise application of old teachings to today’s conditions is far more significant than history for its own sake. We can draw conclusions from past wisdom and distinguish this wisdom from all that is outdated and irrelevant.
We must look further and dig deeper to squeeze the honey from the ancient spiritual traditions that can make a significant contribution to opening our hearts, unfolding our creativity and bringing forth liberating visions. The significance of Tantra is a typical example. It is often undervalued, rejected or misunderstood. Tantra has something truly meaningful to offer the West, once the various false ideas, dark sides and hostile attitudes towards it have been recognised. Tantra has endured many controversies due to questionable actors and interpretations, but those free from such interpretations can explore the blessings of Tantra. Tantra broke away from the orthodoxy of the Buddhist-Hindu tradition, which extolled renunciation and sexual abstinence as an important step towards liberation. Tantrikas proactively embrace the act of love and artistic creativity as vehicles of liberation. Their approach shocked the religious conservatives, monks and yogis of India at the time.
The image of the authentic and liberating tradition of Tantra has suffered for centuries under the projections of Christian missionaries, the hijacking by sex-obsessed Westerners and the abuse by violent devotees of Kali. The original spirit and vision of Tantra sank into philosophical analysis, religious rituals and an aura of mystery. It is now time for Tantra to free itself from the distortions of history in East and West, and from reduction to a science of analysing ancient tantric discourses in Buddhism and Hinduism. It is time to take the best of Tantra and apply it to daily life.
Christian missionaries during the British Raj bear great responsibility for the distortion of the view of Tantra, which they regarded as a violation of human sensibilities, breaking every social taboo and moral convention. This distortion is far from the truth and at best a jealous highlighting of crazy customs, rituals or sacrificial rites of a small minority of followers. It has left the lasting impression that Tantra represents a very dubious, if not dangerous, form of spirituality.
The second wave of interpretation of Tantra in the West in the 20th century associated Tantra exclusively with sex. Tantra meant something like “sacred sex” and was connected with workshops for developing sexual relationships and techniques for couples who had newly met and were exploring their sexual practice. The term “Tantra” legitimised sex as a spiritual activity. “Sacred sex” is connected to genuine Tantra about as much as the genitals are to the rest of the body, but it does not represent the whole. Tantric workshops tend to ignore the tantric teaching as a whole and focus exclusively on the sexual component, although subtle and profound tantric workshops can be of great benefit to the sexual lives of participants. Other tantric teachings strive to make Tantra experienced as a lifestyle and not as a specific area of life.
Tantra expresses a diverse, complex spiritual concept for everyday life and distinguishes itself from any mainstream religion and spiritual orthodoxy. Tantra indeed considers the fundamental significance of energy, sensuality, human nature, our relationship to the body and its implementation, such as the application of mudras. Mudras refer to the use of the hands in relation to symbolic gestures that express certain experiences, such as resting one hand on the other to indicate the mind of meditation or the touching thumb tips of folded hands as an expression of the experience of oneness with life.
Tantra also supports forms of sacred art that depict the constructive and destructive life cycles on a large and small scale. As a symbolic statement, a mandala can express itself through the arts. It involves continuous mindfulness, moment-to-moment concentration and artistic perception. The best-known mandala is probably the sand mandala, painstakingly created by Buddhist monks over weeks and then dissolved again with a few strokes of the hand.
We live in the field of arising and passing away. This is a figurative teaching that reminds us that what is assembled will dissolve again like the mandala, which is wiped away with a hand movement.
According to Tantra, divine cosmic energy radiates through the body, the hands and the consecrated art in the process of awakening humanity.
The spirit and content of Tantra sent shockwaves through the established Buddhist-Hindu doctrines of the 2nd-3rd centuries. The orthodox Indian religions relied on a strict separation of truth seekers between wandering yogis and lay followers (householders), who observed the precepts, earned merits and supported the yogis. Religious beliefs included the view that only yogis, monks and nuns could fully awaken and experience liberation. Tantrikas hardly concerned themselves with this classification into lay followers and yogis, as Tantra encompassed energy, sensuality/sexuality and the arts and also referred to an indivisible spiritual awakening. Tantrikas applied male/female exercises practically for lay followers and symbolically for celibate yogis. The masculine and the feminine became archetypes for non-duality or wisdom and compassion, transcendence and immanence.
This tradition was called Tantra because it refines or carefully elaborates reality (Tattva) to establish what constitutes a spiritual science. Tantra means “to weave, expand, spread”. With its revolutionary impetus, Tantra turned religious practices upside down and helped India from the 3rd century onwards for the next 5 centuries to a golden age of spirituality. The refinement of spiritual practices, the strong commitment to the arts, the mythology and stories of realisation and awakening gave Tantra a decisive significance with regard to establishing a new form of spirituality.
Completely different in nature from Western religion, Tantra today offers a radical alternative both to Western and to some paralysing forms of Eastern religions. With its revolutionary impulses, Tantra has much to offer the Western mind with its interest in integrating energy, science, love, sex and cosmic life.
Instead of overcoming desire and pleasure, a constant theme in the Buddhist-Hindu tradition, Tantra stands for a different kind of approach that tries to use desire and sensuality more as a means for awakening and less as an obstacle. In the emergence and development of the tantric tradition, practitioners tended strongly towards this approach because it included sexual intimacy in its entirety rather than pursuing its overcoming. Tantra devoted meditative attention to life and death, male and female, devotion and creativity. Representing the Hindu gods, tantric masters cultivated stories and art forms. They were inspired by the active romantic and sexual life of the gods, especially Shiva and his consort Parvati, who had given themselves to a creative and passionate dance to express their divinity.
Tantrikas developed subtle instruments (uāaya) to share their sexuality as an expression of cosmic energy and cosmic unity, while yogis used mantras, visualisation exercises, mandalas and breath to harmonise the energies of heart, mind and body, of romance, sexual and otherwise. Instead of resisting sensual energies, they welcomed them as a contribution to energising awareness. It was a radical change in attitude towards what generations of gurus had conveyed to their students and Buddhist abbots to their monks and nuns.
Tantric masters offered initiations (diksha) and empowerment (strengthening, authorisation - abhiseka). The free-spirited attitude of Tantra meant that it was not necessary to identify with a special guru in search of liberating truth. For example, the tantric guru Naropa said to his initiates: “If it should ever happen that one has a teacher without true knowledge and this causes doubt, no harm would come from leaving him. Rather, the knowledge-seeking practitioner goes from master to master, like the bee, eager for honey, flying from flower to flower.”
As a master of the 9th century, Naropa studied discourses of the Buddha and Tantra at Nalanda University in northern India until he set out on a spiritual quest outside the corridors of learning. Eventually he found his master, Nilopa, with whom he undertook numerous spiritual hardships over 12 years. In the Vajrayana tradition of Buddhism, which is regarded as the Buddhist Tantra tradition, Buddhists lovingly remember Naropa and his unwavering loyalty to Nilopa, with both regarded as tantric masters of the monastic tradition.
The original intention of initiation (diksha) was to introduce the practitioner to knowledge, rituals and the tantric community, which understood itself as agama-representing, meaning: without attachment to nigama (the orthodoxy of tradition, such as the Vedas). The treasury of tantric literature is agama (“that which has come to us”) and deals with a variety of spiritual topics.
Many Westerners who devote themselves to Dharma practice in the West would nowadays count themselves as part of the agama tradition. They have little interest in the teachings of the Vedas and prefer the discourses of the Buddha (Sutta Nikaya), which Indian scholars – just like the Yoga Sutras – would consider agama.
While most people in India have remained faithful to the nigama tradition, Tantra practitioners have always been a minority; they were regarded as an esoteric sect, essentially maintaining a non-traditional and non-orthodox philosophy of life.
Agama deals with 3 fundamental paths: spiritual knowledge from ancient non-Vedic texts, oral tradition and contemporary wisdom teachings.
1. Yoga – inner discipline, postures, mudras, meditation, exercises.
2. Art – the construction of temples, sculptures, carvings and paintings including the erotic.
3. Rituals, festivals and pilgrimages
Tantra and Sexuality
Tantrikas offer a significant perspective on the place of sexuality within spiritual exploration, non-duality and the search for truths that free consciousness from the non-ease associated with sexuality. Instead of fleeing the sexual experience, they embraced the fusion of sexual energies through creative and artful acts of lovemaking, including words, sounds and a wide range of body positions while making love. Adepts, one of the names used for tantric masters, demonstrated that passionate, energetic and adventurous lovemaking reflects union with cosmic energy.
It is no surprise that Tantrikas were often regarded as heretics by conservative Buddhists and Hindus! Encouraged to question religious views related to sex, Tantrikas created sculptures of fine art in numerous temples in India as well as erotic art for the home, such as a naked Dakini sitting in the lap of the Buddha. The act of lovemaking thus ultimately gained spiritual significance. The voice of Tantra today finds resonance among those within the agama tradition who regard the separation between lovemaking and celibacy as a false hierarchical divide with no relation to religious impetus or spiritual development.
Tantric Texts
Tantric texts convey teachings that the reader can understand on various levels either as factual or metaphorical. Myths, legends and stories, ancient and modern, were written more to access the depths of the inner life than to remain in analysis, logic and rational thinking. At first glance, a text translated from Sanskrit may seem incomprehensible if taken literally, yet still convey insights on another level of the inner life. The esoteric nature of certain texts makes them extremely difficult to grasp even for the most experienced tantric adepts. Some readers of old texts find a completely new meaning in the old treatise weeks, months, years or decades later when rereading a particular text.
There is the transformation of the incomprehensible to an understanding of certain texts, nigama as well as agama. Mantras (the repetition of a particular phrase or word that vibrates deeply within to create a soul calm that permeates the whole being) and yantras (symbols and geometric shapes, often squares, triangles and circles, which create shapes that lead to the centre) are described in tantric texts. A text may contain lines of poetry reminding the practitioner of the importance of love and intimacy.
“There is no end to bliss
of Madana’s enchanter.
Lying lazily in the arms of the woman,
he thirsts for the taste of the place of love,
While saying lovely things,
he makes love with the beautiful one in the lotus heart of Kamalakanta ”
(Sayama Sangit no 131)
The Sayama Sangit is a Bengali love song from the 13th century, dedicated to the goddess Kali. Sayama refers to her skin colour, often black.
According to the Kularnava (the Ocean of Kula), Tantra is based on 21,600 daily breaths, assumed as the daily basis for a human being. The place of the heart serves as an essential aspect of Tantra.
“On other paths one cannot be a connoisseur of life if one is a yogi. No one who enjoys life is a yogi. This path gives joy of life and yoga and is therefore greater than all other paths.
The knowledge of the heart shines in the one whose consciousness is pure and peaceful, whose actions serve the guru, who is extremely devoted and can keep a secret.
The one who dwells in the heart is a vessel of joy and liberation.
Someone who experiences the bliss of connection in the sexual relationship, as between the highest power and the self, such a person knows the meaning of sexual relationships.
Just as the divine couple is inseparable, so is the goddess Lakshmi inseparable from Narayana and Saraswati from Brahma.
The body is God’s dwelling place. I am He. The experience of captivity in his animal nature is the way of thinking about the embodied self. Freed from identification with this animal nature, one has the experience of the ever-constant Shiva.
There are no commands. There are no prohibitions. There is no heaven and certainly no hell for the disciples of the heart.
Wherever living, whatever disguise and whatever life is assumed and recognised by everyone in whatever social position he or she may be, he or she remains a yogi of the heart.”
Tantra affirms the unorthodox as a true path to complete realisation. The fundamental doctrine of Tantra regards worldly experiences decidedly in the service of awakening rather than as obstacles. A wise approach to spiritual and worldly pleasures serves as a vehicle for gaining insight, realisation and liberation both in heaven and on earth.
The Tantra tradition honours the place of poetry, music, sacred dance, theatre, meditation, sensuality and familiarity with spiritual depths – a revolutionary alternative to precepts, strict forms and beliefs of conventional religions. Currently, many Buddhists place an exaggerated emphasis on meditation and mindfulness in daily life, so that far too many Westerners judge their own spiritual development through a narrow prism. It is time to embrace the inherent diversity of spiritual exploration in Tantra within Western culture, leaving behind those elements of Tantra in the East that rely on secret initiations, rituals and a dark past.
Tantrikas learn to release their vitality and energy to enable the transformation of consciousness. Through conscious engagement with all the senses, eyes, ears, nose, tongue and touch, reality expands and offers spiritual nourishment and depth. This use of passion, love and energy gives Tantrikas the ability to engage with divine and ecstatic experiences and to lift consciousness out of the everyday. Tantrikas use the arts to evoke sensuality and illuminate life, rather than reduce it to temporary entertainment.
Tantrikas regard life as a mandala of wondrous interactive events that arise from the formless.
One of the Indian tantric texts bears the title “Garland of Jewels”, a title that succinctly expresses the application and vision of Tantra. Tantric intimacy treats sexuality and the arts as belonging to a divine path. The Tantrika embraces Shiva and Shakti, lovers and singles, wisdom and love, yogis and yoginis, visionaries and healers. The impetus of Tantra supports a variety of practices applied in imaginative and liberating ways, referring to or releasing the cultural/religious background of the participants.
Tantric texts contradict the structure of orthodox religious views to explore the mandala of love, culture and spirituality. The tantric master offers initiations in intimacy, sharing of the heart, mind and body on the basis of virtue and wisdom. These practices contribute to the integration of the fabric of daily encounters and offer fulfilment through weaving together the development of perceptions with cultural depths to reveal the fundamental truth. Esteemed advocates of Tantra include Nagarjuna, the Indian teacher of the 3rd century, who advocated the emptiness of self-existence.
Seven chakras
The union of man and woman serves as a metaphor for the union of wisdom and energy. The emphasis on transformation through meditation, insight and a different attitude takes precedence over the effort to renounce worldly desire, personal needs and various forms of attachment. Tantrikas acknowledge the risk of inflating the ego or developing a deluded view through full engagement in every arena of life. They consider this risk worthwhile in view of the potential for a great breakthrough into an awakened life, far-reaching and comprehensive.
Tantra has adopted the meditative use, application and practice of chakras (wheels), which are regarded as essential accumulations of energy or life force. By calmly and concentratively focusing on a chakra, the Tantrika establishes its importance as a step towards full awakening. The chakras serve the practitioner as a reminder of the fundamental areas of significance for a human being.
The most common seven locations for the chakras are:
1. Crown of the head
2. Forehead area between the eyes
3. Throat
4. Centre of the chest
5. Solar plexus
6. Navel
7. Base of the spine
The crown chakra represents our relationship to the cosmos, the sky above us, the night sky and the immeasurable meaning of the whole. In this chakra we experience the transcendent instead of the concerns of the self.
The forehead (third eye) chakra stands for consciousness. We often have the impression that our so-called “I” is located in a region above and behind the eyes, from where we look at the world. This chakra enables a clear view of mental contents. Awareness reveals the content and the content reveals awareness.
The throat chakra represents language. Our voice forms words, sounds, chants, mantras and songs that reach others, people, animals, reptiles and much more and also vibrates through our being.
The heart chakra represents our feelings, emotions, passion and love. We direct energy into this chakra to expand our heart to everything far and wide, including our life.
The solar plexus chakra stands for energy, willingness to take risks, the power to act. Sometimes we know that we have to take a risk. We feel a sensation in the area of the solar plexus. This is the wheel of the chakra struggling to turn.
The belly chakra represents nourishment and sexuality. Although it is called a lower chakra by some, it is not to be regarded as a subordinate chakra. We must use energy for healthy nutrition, mindful eating with respectful expression of sexuality and considered views on love life.
The root chakra represents our connection to the earth, our sense of life and our corporeality. This chakra reminds us of the importance of matter, the mere elements.
Although the chakras imply a physical location, Tantrikas perceive each of these chakras as an important element of psychological life and through the alignment of meditative attention on each chakra, this chakra gains lively and divine energy. Each chakra has a place and meaning to remind practitioners of the elemental importance of paying attention to each of the 7 chakras for a holistic and balanced life. Any neglect of these wheels (chakras), which transform our life, brings about an unwise, clumsy use of energy with the restlessness, confusion and suffering that accompanies such neglect.
Tantric practitioners reflect on the significance of each chakra to become clear about which they should develop or meditate on in order to experience the unadulterated wholeness as a human being. The shift from isolation to the collective, from the reader through Tantra to being in the community of practitioners helps to ensure the turning of each wheel (chakra) and allows our life to move easily and freely.
In the West there are teachers who rely on the chakras as explored in Tantra. There are teachers in the West who offer instructions in the release and application of energy as in Tantra. There are teachers who offer Tantra exclusively as a sexual practice. Tantra is also illustrated in science when science expands our understanding and our wonder.
Traditional, modern and postmodern art, whether sculpture, painting, music, dance, poetry, literature, theatre or cinema, contains an element of Tantra when the art form reveals insights and inspiration for our daily life to the audience as well as to the artists. With its emphasis on refinement, expansion and interweaving, Tantra honours the gifts and creative practices that open our consciousness.
Certain teachings, spiritual, religious, psychological and scientific, can focus on one of the chakras from the upper chakra (cosmic consciousness) down to the root chakra (intimacy with the earth) and expand. While specialising in the various chakra wheels as a tangible reminder of what matters is to be welcomed, few representatives of Tantra embody the richness of tantric teachings, whether monks, nuns, yogis or householders. An eager bee may have to fly from flower to flower, as Naropa noted, to rely on the pollen. Such a seeker needs mindful presence towards teachers, teachings and centres. Seekers pay attention to their ethics, values, attitudes and responsibility for workshops and retreats.
Once again, Tantra emphasises the need for the Tantrika to remember that what he or she perceives as an obstacle actually serves as a vehicle for change, for integration. There is therefore no need for householders and yogis to cling to any identity - whether as householder or wandering yogi - as each of them has the same chance to develop. Some lamas of the Buddhist tradition of Tantra have offered secret texts, such as the Guhyagarbha Tantra with its “hidden core”, to those who have been initiated. Initiates may have received empowerment for the “Vajrasattva’s magical manifestation matrix” (regarded as Tantra of enlightenment) to read the sacred book. It may be the mysterious that is often associated with Tantra that stems from the early origins of Tantra in connection with the exploration of physical intimacy on the path of practice.
Core aspects of Tantra are:
- Action
- Behaviour
- Attitude
- Initiations
- Movement
- Mudras
- Presentation
- Rituals
- Sexual union
- Touch
- Yoga
- Highest yoga (Yoga Niruttara – with no higher)
Tantra Transcends Boundaries
Tantra fundamentally gives practitioners permission to explore outside the accepted parameters of what most people would consider possible and permissible. Some people found it difficult to tune in to yogis who followed no special discipline, belonged to no particular school and followed or submitted to no particular precepts, rules and vows. In an 18th-century tantric text from the Vajrayana tradition, “The Laughter of the Dakinis”, it says:
“I, who feel so united, practise to unite samsara and nirvana, dance on the deities and spirits of the ego, which reduces the discursive thought of transmigration, dualities, to dust.”
The recorded practices of Tantra are mainly contained in old books, and only a small number have been translated from Sanskrit into English. Some Tantrikas wrote books that were incomprehensible to most readers because these books accompanied the teachings of a tantric master. Without the master, the books made little or no sense. Buddhist and Hindu scholars generally agree that it is not possible to summarise Tantra due to the diversity of approaches to numerous aspects of spiritual exploration. Tantra leaves little untried in spiritual life, although it lacks a political and global perspective.
The relationship between guru and sadhaka (spiritual practitioner) forms an important connection in Tantra due to the combination of trust based on the evidence of the guru’s wisdom and trust based on the evidence of the sadhaka’s aspirations and determinations. A sadhaka is someone who follows a particular sadhana (literally: ‘the means to an end’). Sadhaka, sadhana, also refers to the word sadhu, derived from the verb root sadh - ‘to accomplish’. One who has not yet reached the goal of awakening is called a sadhaka, while one who has reached the goal is called a siddha. Generations of Buddhist sadhakas called the Buddha Gautama Siddhartha: Gautama, the accomplished.
Female principles and energy influenced the original ideas and development of Tantra through the equal recognition of goddesses, a non-patriarchal approach to spirituality, the unity and non-duality of genders, with stories and art forms expressing equality between men and women, gods and goddesses. As mentioned in another essay, Shiva sat in the cave in full lotus position in deep meditation. Parvati, the queen of the Himalayas, sat in exactly the same position in front of Shiva, a sadhu (ascetic). Shiva did not try to send her away so that he could remain a solitary yogi (as opposed to the Buddha), but welcomed her into his cave. This historical-mythological event established the intimacy of Shiva and Parvati. The dancer and the dance (Shiva and Parvati, wisdom and skill, knowledge and compassion) became one.
Since Tantra does not fit into a simple category, it seems hardly possible to find a definition for Tantra, also because it knows no boundaries. Considering the usual Western use of the word “Tantra” in connection with sacred sex, it is time to restore a broader understanding of spirituality that characterises Tantra. While using the old Agama texts, Tantra remains primarily an oral tradition with teachers selecting aspects of Tantra that they use for the welfare of the sadhakas and offering the full inclusion of the body in spiritual practice through nutrition, sexuality, physical presence and cell building. Tantrikas pay loving attention to the energy in all their cells and subatomic particles. They treat these cells as a divine element that can reveal light and enlightenment.
Through meditation and yoga, tantric practitioners gained access to kundalini energy, often described as a coiled snake or coiled power. In the depths of rest, through the release of tension and stress, the cells release energy that travels through the body to strengthen the whole being and consciousness. Like a stream of electricity, kundalini energy can move through the body to evoke all kinds of states of mystical experiences, shifts in consciousness and visions. The “reality” of the usual worldview can be replaced by a new perspective that appears just as real as the previous version of reality.
In Tantra, the guidance of a wise master is crucial, especially in the area of sexuality, chakras and kundalini practice. Otherwise, there is a risk that the seeker will try to achieve results through inexperience or the use of willpower, creating dangerous pressure. The inner life can connect the energies of heart, mind, body and consciousness. This requires skill and an appropriate methodology to experience the immediate benefit of such statements of Tantra. This requires the guidance of the master.
With virtuous behaviour as an indispensable factor, energy, sexual intimacy, chakras and kundalini energy can be harmonised to make deep experiences of our human capacities, which are often ignored and neglected. Love is a subtle and powerful energy that contributes to the dissolution of coarse behaviour and blocked energy, including negative and anxious energies, through skilful actions and understanding.
A skilful sadhana contributes immensely to finding our way into the heart of Tantra, while an unskilful sadhana can drive a person insane. Tantra requires vigilance and empathy with oneself and others to protect all involved from confusion and disorder. We develop Tantra to establish a deep well-being, harmony with the rhythm of life, a healthy lifestyle and direct knowledge of liberation amidst the cosmic dance. Tantra reminds us of the way life expands, comes together and weaves.
A rehabilitated Tantra has much to offer Western life. Tantra has the ability to awaken us from the dream of ordinary life, challenge adherence to fixed norms and unfold a creative and liberated passion."
