non-dual Tantra Philosophytantra-philosophy: non-dual, classical Tantra

Non-dual, Kashmiri and classical Tantra or also Śaiva-Tantra or non-dual Śiva-Śakti-Tantra (NŚT) are often used synonymously. The non-dual Tantra Philosophy includes duality, which begins with language and every subject-object relationship. It goes intimately with reality itself. And it does not linger in the pursuit of something that should bring happiness and fulfilment. Non-dual Tantra reminds us that we ourselves are already what we had been searching for. And so it contains far more than answers to questions about fulfilling sexuality, ideas about personality development, man and woman, enlightenment or other topics. Non-dual Tantra does not linger in ideas and concepts. 

Unlike religious systems of thought, such as Evangelicalism or Islam, "belief" does not play a prominent role in Tantra Philosophy. Belief arises from duality, from projections and attributions of meaning, and from the splitting of experience into object and subject (I and Not-I, the believer and the believed). From a non-dual tantric perspective, God therefore cannot be an opposite. If we fear her or him, then we fear ourselves; strictly speaking, however, we only fear a story that we project as a dream in which we have immersed ourselves and lost ourselves. If we seek her or his salvation, we seek it in a story borrowed from our socially constructed reality or, similar to the Apostle Paul, perhaps even invented ourselves, and which we believe. Belief means giving a felt reality to an idea. We do this by endowing it with bodily sensations. But what is reality beyond belief?

Tantra is a path of discovering and experiencing the reality that grounds itself, which cannot be objectified intellectually or linguistically. While what I am writing here may sound rather dull, contentless and yet factually "reasonable", the Tantras and tantric teachers use an "elliptical", suggestive, often contradictory, transgressive and seemingly incomprehensible language that can express the impossible and bring us to the edge of the experience of the unspeakable. This is probably also Tantra's greatest achievement. To be a kind of self-referential service of consciousness to remember itself and reflect its own insurmountable subjectivity. 

Necessarily, there can be no enlightening words, as they are at best only a (infinitely small) subset of what they should represent. And similarly, as the Buddha for the same reason used 112 synonyms for the term "awakening" in his teachings, classical Tantra has numerous interwoven conceptual reference systems that, although highly redundant among themselves, can practically never be thought of simultaneously, but only experienced. The diversification and cultivation of the various non-dual tantric lines (Kaula, Krama, Trika ...) with their specific traditions and approaches can also be understood as an expression of this.

 

Definition of "Tantra"

What does the term actually mean? The Sanskrit word "Tantra" actually means nothing more than "teaching", "theory", possibly "system" or simply "book" and refers to texts (so-called Tantras) that appeared in India from the 6th century AD and were written in large numbers in the following centuries. Each Tantra represents its own, largely complete system of spiritual practice. Practitioners might have asked each other back then: "Which Tantra do you follow?"

The term "classical Tantra" refers to the actual, transmitted core essence of Tantra Philosophy. Terms such as "non-dual Śiva-Śakti-Tantra (NŚT)", "Śaiva-Tantra", "Kashmiri Tantrism" or "Kashmiri Tantra" are largely used synonymously. The latter because the great masters in the valleys of Kashmir and Uḍḍiyāna at that time significantly contributed to the development of Tantra Philosophy and practice of classical Tantra (see e.g. also here ->Kashmiri Shaivism).

 

Tantra Philosophy and Expansion

How did the narrative of "expansion / interweaving" that is now widespread especially in the Neotantra scene come about? In the earliest Sanskrit, Tantra meant "loom", and later the roots "Atan" (to spread, elaborate, expand) and "Atra" (to save, protect) can be found, which may have quickly led to this more general interpretation: Tantra is a tool (tra) that serves the expansion (tan) of wisdom (or the awareness of our divine nature). "Expansion" in a non-dualistic understanding would indeed mean here to expand into what is, what we really are. And practices (Upāyas) that are meant to bring God in their contracted form of the limited and attached ego into awareness and are described in the Tantras serve this purpose. 

Sanskrit scholars point out however that Sanskrit has changed over millennia, and the meanings "loom" and "expansion" lie much further in the past. The oldest known temple inscription of terms like "Tantra" and "Dakini" (awakened tantric female masters) dates from the year 423 AD. At the time of the emerging Tantrism, the meaning described above is to be assumed, although it is also assumed that the old meanings somehow still resonated as connotations.

"Expanding" and "interweaving" are not without a certain appeal to describe the essence of non-dual Tantra Philosophy, especially when it comes to the movement from judging towards ever further differentiating or letting go of self-concepts in favour of the underlying reality that brings forth and includes any experience (and thus also any notion of limitation). 

 

Limited Identity Creates Duality

When we follow a non-dual tantric path, we quickly sense that our previous certainties and concepts about ourselves and the world, all beliefs about them and attachments to them do not carry us far. Strictly speaking, they never carried us; we just thought so. They are a provisional measure, nothing more. From the perspective of Tantra Philosophy, they are mental constructs, dualistic concepts (Vikalpas), not the truth about reality, which cannot be experienced in the world of duality and limited identities. Or, expressed differently: Śiva (the formless ground) contracted into an identification, into a limited viewpoint of its consciousness and necessarily had to exclude everything else from itself, because otherwise an identity that does not encompass everything would not be possible. This contraction enabled Śiva to bring forth limitations ("veils" or "armour", the so-called kañcukas), such as limited efficacy (kalā), limited knowledge (vidyā), passion (rasa), time (kāla) and causality (niyati). And necessarily he/she entangles himself/herself in the result, which can also be called "duality", the world of objects and subject-object relationships.

Why does he/she do this? For the joy of experience! And: why should it serve anything else than to be what it is? One explanation by Abhinavagupta was: Śiva brought forth Śakti (the forces, the universe, the world of duality) from himself to lose himself in it, out of pure joy to find himself again. The latter can also be understood as the love that welcomes the connecting, which is everywhere, envelops and penetrates everything and ultimately - like everything - is everything. This view is expressed in various tantric traditions in many ways.

If we then follow the tantric philosophy and continue on a spiritual path that leaves attachments to ideas behind, we eventually realise that we have also passed a kind of "point of no return" and can no longer return to something we recognise as something that was always an illusion, while at the same time sensing that it also makes no sense to replace an old belief with a new one. The ego, identified with its self-concepts, repeatedly tries to cling to something reliable and is often very persistent and resourceful (after all, it is a contracted form of God). None of this is ultimately convincing, however, when we have tasted the flavour of ease and freedom on the tantric path - or, strictly speaking - have remembered that what was bound only existed as a story. And that there is no self that could be unfree. It would have to be free from itself, but then it would not know of its freedom.

 

"Inner Child"

In a way, leaving behind our attachments to certainties also resembles looking back at our family and our childhood socialisation when growing up. We notice that we no longer believe in Santa Claus, and we also no longer believe in many other things that were once certainties for us. We recognise that in school and family we were given a kind of "starter kit" to start with, an initial equipment for orientation in this life in a human body, for provisional coping in the socially constructed reality that is just such-and-such. And from now on, it is up to us what we want to believe and ultimately take responsibility for our lives. Because there is no one else who has the authority to interpret it. This can be a good reason to address the "inner child", because here we repeatedly come into contact with deeply anchored imprints or deep conditioning (Saṃskāras) in our experiential apparatus, which led to judgments and beliefs about ourselves, the world, life and our roles in it (Vikālpas). In this respect, Tantra and tantric courses have enormous liberating and ultimately "therapeutic" potential, as these conditionings are gradually dissolved with the help of various tantric practices.

However, unlike therapy, non-dual Tantra Philosophy does not pursue a teleology in the sense of a healing intention. Because what is already perfect cannot be healed. What is called "healing" elsewhere (in the sense of repairing an objectively experienced damage or filling a perceived deficiency) ultimately corresponds in non-dual thinking to the expansion of identification up to the identity of Śiva consciousness. What is elsewhere - with a bit of luck - perhaps called "psychotherapy" happens in classical Tantrism rather incidentally through the shedding of identification with a story and the reabsorption of the emotional charge (psychotherapy usually deals with the reconfiguration of our beliefs about reality and pursues the foundation of belief in the dualistic experience of individuality, e.g. in the sense of so-called "ego strengthening").

 

Tantra Philosophy and Other Spiritual Systems of Thought

The view on thinking, concepts and other mental constructs does not differ in every respect in classical Tantra Philosophy from the perspective of other non-dualistic systems of thought, such as Buddhism or Patañjali's Ashtānga Yoga ("the 8 aids to Yoga", whereby Patañjali understood "Yoga" as the goal state of the silence of objectless Samādhi and not as a practice. Patañjali's Yoga is not to be confused with Hatha Yoga, which stems from the tantric tradition), at least not regarding their illusory nature. However, most of these spiritual systems - except for a few, such as Tibetan Buddhism - adhere to the notion that worldly desires must be overcome to free the mind. Because, as we notice sooner or later, desire only leads to painful entanglements and restlessness of the mind, and because no ideal or material phenomenon can make us happy (from a Buddhist perspective, for example, the "emptiness" {anatta} and the unsatisfactory nature of things {dukkha} due to their impermanence {annica}). Therefore, the body is undervalued or considered illusory in these systems, and it is necessary to "transcend" it. Another example of this transcendentalism is the teaching of Ramana Mahāṛśi, probably the best-known teacher of Advaita Vedānta, who died in the mid-20th century from a plasmacytoma that he did not treat because he attributed no significance to the body, while he found liberation in exploring the question "who am I?". Early Buddhism and Vedanta are characterised by the fact that the "goal state" of the realisation of spiritual practice is adynamic, i.e. it is a resting in the presence of the eternal ground of being in a kind of witness consciousness that looks at the unlit objects of awareness (a translation of Nirvāna or Nibbāna is "no fire") in the eternal cycle of becoming and passing away. In Tantra, however, willing and acting (Icchā-Śakti and Kriyā-Śakti) are understood as qualities inherent in consciousness itself, which find their expression in the world (Maya, Samsara), their "place", which is boundless space-time, but is never left.

Regarding the development of Kashmiri Tantra Philosophy, it may be interesting to consider that the Buddha and Patañjali lived around the same time, at a time that was very atheistically influenced. And one could understand it as both providing counter-models to the institutionalised understanding of spirituality in Indian society at the time. Both also designed an eightfold path of liberation or awakening (or to what they each understood by it), whereby Patañjali's teaching was inspired by that of the Buddha. Yāmas and niyāmas (virtues or ways of life to enable Yoga), asāna (by the way only 1 simple body position in classical Yoga!), pranayāma (cultivation of breath awareness), patyahāra (collection), dharāna (concentration), dhyāna (meditation on the breath as an object with gentle effort) and samādhi (awareness of the object without any effort) lead to Yoga, the goal (awareness without object, also called nirodha; here there are also analogies to the stages of deepening of Buddhist Jhāna meditation).

This transcendental exploration and experience of the spiritual was quite interesting for the ancient tantrics, but they also recognised that it cannot encompass all aspects of our existence. This, and the emerging Krishna movement inspired by the Bhagavad Gītā, shifted the focus to the development of a spirituality for life "in the world", which - together with the emerging Shaivism - ultimately founded the classical non-dual Tantra Philosophy.

Spirituality at that time was largely based on the ritualised recitations of the Vedas by Brahmin priests, who thereby - probably similar to the practice of indulgences in Catholicism or also the guilty penitence and enthusiastic search of today's Evangelicals for responsibility outside themselves - provided a social hygiene instrument that Karl Marx might have called "opium for the people". For the Buddha, the latter was reflected in the "falseness" of the courtly life of his dysfunctional family (see also: C. Titmuss: "The explicit Buddha"), which he therefore left (and even his newborn son Rahula), to ultimately consider all worldly and also spiritual desire (after all the effort with which he devoted himself completely to spiritual discipline and asceticism for 6 years - with the goal of overcoming the worldly and finding "liberation") as painful. The peace of Nirvana was thus found by the Buddha beyond desire. He analysed and deconstructed the self and reality into 5 aggregates of existence and had no "higher self" in mind. He was only interested in awakening in reality itself. Patañjali, on the other hand, sought - similar to the Buddha's teachers - liberation in yogic discipline with the aim of reaching the unfiltered awareness of reality ("Yoga") free of any activity of body-mind, which was understood as a "higher" or only true consciousness. This "true consciousness" is understood from a tantric perspective as a kind of adynamic witness consciousness.

Although Tantrism had largely assimilated the philosophy and practices of the Buddha and Patañjali, Tantra Philosophy nevertheless has a fundamentally different view of reality. Body and mind are here immanent expressions of precisely this reality. Both are also expressions of a continuum, whereby the body is the "most tangible" manifestation of the mind and the mind the subtlest manifestation of the body. Desire, which often revolves around the contracted identification with the body and/or aspects of its functioning in the world, is seen as a natural expression of our nature. Tantra is therefore neither transcendentalist nor ascetic. Even the painful experiences that arise when desire becomes a grasping for something are recognised in Tantra Philosophy as expressions of the real. Ultimately, Tantra is about the awareness of the embodied soul (Jīvanmukti).

The 25 Tattvas ("fundamental principles of reality") that Patañjali formulated and borrowed from the dualistic Saṃkhya philosophy underlying Vedanta also seemed insufficient to the ancient tantrics: They defined a further 11 (sometimes more) Tattvas (in Tantra Philosophy there are therefore a total of 36+ Tattvas), which further differentiate the aspects of the spiritual. And - unlike in Patañjali Yoga - the enumeration begins with the earth element, which alone can represent all other principles of reality.

You can find more details about this at tantrailluminated.org and in Christopher Wallis's work "Light on Tantra".

In the end, it becomes clear to us that it is futile to grasp for something that we ourselves are. Or, put differently: God spared no effort to be exactly what you are (strictly speaking, she enjoys her creativity in doing so). To contract into this identity that you are, God had to exclude all other identified beings with whatever or whoever. Everything in, with and around us is therefore nothing other than an expression of the divine. There is nothing else. This is also reflected in the much broader Indian greeting gesture (añjali mudrā) in Tantra: "I honour (or greet) the divine in you in me" (or bow before it).

Further background texts on Tantra Philosophy and Tantra Yoga practice can be found on our site and elsewhere.